Lab Diamond vs Moissanite — Which is Right for You?

Both lab diamonds and moissanite are smart alternatives to mined diamonds. At Heritage & Co., we stock both — and we'll give you an honest comparison so you can decide with confidence.

At a Glance

Lab Diamond (Claritas) Moissanite (Aeterna)
What it is Real diamond, grown above ground Silicon carbide gemstone
Hardness 10 (Mohs) 9.25 (Mohs)
Brilliance High Higher (more fire, more sparkle)
Certification IGI (D/VVS1 standard; D/FL and D/IF on 0.5 to 1.5ct) GRA (D colour, VVS1)
Metal Solid 10K, 14K or 18K gold Solid 10K–14K gold
Starting price From R13,000 R19,500
Lead time Approximately five weeks Approximately five weeks
Warranty 20-year defect warranty 20-year defect warranty

Lab Diamonds — What You Need to Know

A lab-grown diamond is chemically and physically identical to a mined diamond — same carbon crystal structure, same hardness (10 Mohs), same refractive index. The only difference is that it was grown in a laboratory rather than mined from the earth. Lab diamonds are certified by the International Gemological Institute (IGI) using the same 4Cs grading scale used for mined diamonds.

Heritage & Co.'s Claritas collection features IGI certified lab grown diamonds in solid gold. Prices start at R13,000 — significantly less than equivalent mined diamonds, but reflecting the premium nature of a certified diamond in solid gold.

Choose a lab diamond if: you want a certified diamond, you're comparing to mined diamond prices (lab grown diamonds generally sell for considerably less), or the "it's a real diamond" factor matters to you or your partner.

Moissanite — What You Need to Know

Moissanite is a lab-grown gemstone made from silicon carbide — not a diamond simulant, but a distinct gemstone with its own unique properties. Moissanite is harder than sapphire or ruby (9.25 Mohs), highly resistant to scratching and chipping, and produces more fire (rainbow dispersion) than a diamond. It is GRA-certified and available in D–F colourless grades.

Heritage & Co.'s Aeterna collection features GRA-certified moissanite in solid 10K and 14K gold, from R19,500. For buyers who want an exceptional-looking stone in solid gold at a fraction of diamond pricing, moissanite is an outstanding choice.

Choose moissanite if: you want maximum value, you prefer a stone that's unique rather than a diamond equivalent, or you want to allocate more budget to the setting, wedding, or honeymoon.

The Honest Verdict

Neither is "better" — they serve different buyers. Moissanite offers extraordinary value and a distinctive look. Lab diamonds offer the prestige and certification of a real diamond at a fraction of the mined diamond price. Both come in solid gold. Both have a 20-year warranty. Both ship free across South Africa.

The question is simply: what matters more to you?

Browse lab diamond rings → Browse moissanite rings →